Balanskat, Blamire & Kefala (2006),
conducted a study carried out in national, international, and European
schools, with the aim of gathering evidence regarding the advantages and
benefits of ICT in school achievements. The study sought to measure the
impact of ICT on student performance by trying to establish a link
between the use of ICT and students’ results in exams. The findings are
interesting. ICT has shown a positive impact on student performance in
primary school, particularly in English language, although the effects
are less significant in the sciences. Schools with higher levels of
e-maturity (E-maturity is demonstrated when students apply ICT in
strategic and discriminating ways, taking into consideration a balance
of advantages and alternatives.) show a rapid increase in performances
in scores compared to those with lower levels.
In addition, schools with adequate ICT
resources achieve better results than those that are not so
well-equipped. There appears to be a direct correlation to
well-appointed ICT schools and a significant improvement on learners’
performances. Finally, many teachers are convinced that educational
achievements of pupils are due to high ICT utilization. In fact, a high
percentage of teachers in Europe (86%), state that pupils are more
motivated when computers and the internet are being used in class.
Many pupils consider ICT tools very
helpful for completing assignments. Also, teachers are attuned to the
fact that ICT enables students with special needs or difficulties to
achieve and grow as well. ICT may also help to reduce social
disparities between pupils, since they work in teams in order to achieve
a given task or common goal. Additionally, students often assume more
responsibilities when they use ICT, such as organizing their work
through digital portfolios or projects. The study also showed that ICT
has had a significant impact on teachers and the teaching processes.
Government interventions and training
seminars have encouraged the use of ICT tools to stimulate teachers.
Indeed, an absolute majority of teachers in Europe (90 %), claim to use
ICT to complete tasks such as preparing lessons and sequencing classroom
activities. Therefore, by utilizing ICT, teachers are able to plan
their lessons more efficiently. ICT also helps teachers to work in teams
and share ideas related to their school’s curriculum. There is also
evidence that broadband (a form of high speed internet) and interactive
whiteboards play a central role in fostering teachers’ communications
and help to increase collaboration between educators.
The ICT Test Bed Evaluation (Underwood
2006), provides evidence that many teachers use ICT to support
innovative education. The report states, “New technologies that provide a
good fit with existing practices, such as interactive whiteboards, are
first to be embedded, but others, like video conferencing, digital video
and virtual learning environments are now being incorporated, providing
evidence of ongoing learning by the workforce. Training needs to
continue to support innovative pedagogy.”
Both of these examples show that ICT is
continuously being integrated into the traditional classroom setting.
Therefore, ICT can improve teaching by enhancing prior knowledge and
introducing new ways of teaching and learning. Transforming teaching is
more difficult to achieve, “changes that take full advantage of ICT will
only happen slowly over time, and only if teachers continue to
experiment with new approaches.” (Underwood 2006) This evaluation came
from a teacher training seminar in Information and Technology (IT)
during the Information Technology Management Forum (ITMF) project. It
demonstrates that teachers have not fully adopted the use of ICT in
education. However, many educators continue to change their way of
thinking about the application of ICT in education and the learning
process.
Accordingly, although many teachers have
increased their use of ICT in lessons where students look for
information on the internet and then use it afterwards for subject
specific areas, hardly any teachers use ICT for class presentations.
Furthermore, teachers do not use ICT to engage students more actively to
produce knowledge. Similarly, the e-learning Nordic 2006 study shows an
increase in the use of ICT to teach but not to innovate teaching
methods, stating, “ICT generally has a positive impact on teaching and
learning situations, but compared with the ideal expectations; the
impact of ICT on teaching and learning must still be considered to be
limited.” (Ramboll, 2006).
Many teachers use ICT to support
traditional learning methods, for example, information retrieval in
which students are ‘passive learners of knowledge’ instead of ‘active
producers, able to take part in the learning process.’ In a document
entitled Teaching and Learning with ICT, G. Galea (2002), it is
explained how ICT can promote teaching and learning. According to
Galea, there are two main reasons to increase the use of ICT in
education in the United Kingdom. First, ICT can change the lessons’
pace. She states that children in modern society need to develop
sufficient skills to take full advantage of the new opportunities that
ICT offers. Secondly, there is a growing rise of academic interest in
the UK, especially in how technological tools can enhance the quality of
teaching and learning in schools, and by doing so, help learners to
achieve better outcomes.
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar